Generative AI's Normative Rationality
Epistemic and Political Implications for the University
This lecture examines how generative AI models produce specific forms of normativity, assign a distinctive subject position to the user, and claim epistemic authority. Will the university relinquish its autonomy by training students to become data annotators, evaluators, and improvers of generated content, subjecting them to AI’s normative rationality? Or will it cultivate their capacity to act as responsible social subjects and participate in ongoing processes of emancipation?
This lecture examines how generative AI models produce specific forms of normativity, assign a distinctive position to the user, and claim an epistemic authority that emerges from what I describe as a “gaze from everywhere.” It argues that these normative operations are inseparable from generative AI’s political economy. At the current stage of capital accumulation, AI systems depend upon and reinforce the concentration of wealth and power in the hands of a very few, at the expense of the majority. This concentration of power shapes both the values embedded in models through post-training and their alignment with state interests in the race for AI supremacy between the United States and China. Generative AI’s environmental harms, substantial energy demands, and financial barriers to accessing the most advanced models impose unequal burdens, with disenfranchised populations and the Global South bearing the brunt of the negative impacts. In this context, the university must confront the question of its own autonomy and educational purpose: will it relinquish its autonomy to generative AI and train students to become data annotators, evaluators, and improvers of generated content, thereby subjecting them to AI’s normative rationality, or will it cultivate their capacity to act as autonomous and responsible social subjects?
The following morning, a supplementary workshop will offer the opportunity of a more comprehensive engagement with Prof. Schwerzmanns research:
Workshop | Friday, November 20, 2026; 10:15-11:45 am
Seminarraum EG004, Hotel Grauer Bär
We will discuss the paper “From Enclosure to Foreclosure and Beyond: Opening AI’s Totalizing Logic.” (AI & Society, https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-026-03024-7) with Prof. Schwerzmann.
Please send an email to ki-entzaubern@uibk.ac.at in order to register for the workshop.
Katia Schwerzmann is a philosopher of media and technology whose work explores the intersections of embodiment, politics, and technology. She is currently a researcher at the SFB Virtuelle Lebenswelten at Ruhr University Bochum, where she previously served as Interim Professor at the Institute of Media Studies, and an associate researcher at the Kulturwissenschaftliches Institut (KWI) in Essen, Germany. Her current research examines how contemporary algorithmic rationality shapes knowledge, subjectivity, and sociality. Her work has appeared in AI & Society, Philosophy & Technology, Social Text, Big Data & Society, Appareil, and Revue des sciences humaines, among other journals.
Campus Innrain
Geiwi-Turm
Hörsaal HS 2 (EG)
Innrain 52d
6020 Innsbruck
Teilnahme
Eintritt frei
Veranstalter
Philosophie
Medien, Gesellschaft und Kommunikation
Forschungszentrum Innsbruck Media Studies
PDFs und Links