Home - Universität Innsbruck
Logo der Medizinischen Universität Innsbruck

Veranstaltungen · Universität Innsbruck · Medizinische Universität Innsbruck

Mittwoch, 29.03.2023


Cosmic Purpose and Epistemic Self-Trust

16:45 Uhr
Seminarraum VI der Theologischen Fakultät , Karl-Rahner-Platz 3, 1.Stock

Anmeldung ist nicht erforderlich

Eintritt / Kosten: Keine


John Pittard

Professor Pittard is an Associate Professor of Philosophy of Religion at Yale Divinity School. His book, Disagreement, Deference, and Religious Commitment (Oxford University Press, 2019), assesses the challenge that religious disagreement poses to confident religious (or irreligious) commitment. Much of Prof. Pittard’s work in progress focuses on arguments that purport to show that some worldview or metaphysical outlook is rationally incompatible with epistemic self-trust.

Weitere Informationen

Cartesian skeptical arguments press skeptical worries by identifying skeptical scenarios that are allegedly compatible with our evidence. But these scenarios are presented as mere possibilities; typically, no positive reason is given for thinking that any such scenario is probable. By contrast, a “positive reason” skeptical argument challenges some outlook by showing that, on the supposition that the outlook is true, it is probable that a skeptical scenario obtains. I argue that positive reason arguments present a more serious skeptical concern than standard Cartesian skeptical arguments. Moreover, a great many outlooks fall prey to positive reason skeptical arguments. Indeed, I contend that positive reason skepticism can be reasonably resisted only by those who affirm that the world is fundamentally ordered towards goodness. But does this conclusion provide a good reason to affirm such cosmic teleology? I argue that it may, defending this answer by appealing to a modest pragmatism.

online via https://webconference.uibk.ac.at/b/joh-fqp-8ve-vsb


Institut für Christliche Philosophie
ICPR - Innsbruck Center for Philosophy of Religion
Doktoratskolleg Religionsphilosophie